The Prep Blog

Covering high school sports in Tacoma, Pierce County and the South Sound

NOTICE: The Prep Blog has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved The Prep Blog.
Visit the new section.

Did bad sportsmanship or mass disorientation reign in Class 2A state boys soccer finals?

Post by Todd Milles / The News Tribune on May 29, 2013 at 12:06 pm with 6 Comments »
May 30, 2013 9:02 am

Hurt feelings are bound to linger for a while in light of what transpired in the Class 2A state boys’ soccer finals Saturday in Sumner.

Cheney High School, a hard-luck runner-up four times over the past five 2A tournaments, finally brought home the championship hardware with a 2-1 overtime victory over Tyee High School at Sunset Chev Stadium.

Ian Scimandle maneuvered through the Tyee defense in overtime to score the game-winning goal. It was the Blackhawks’ first state title in soccer.

* The Spokesman-Review game story is here.

* The Seattle Times game story is here.

* The News Tribune game story is here.

The point of debate occurred in the 30th minute, or late in the first half. That is when Tyee gained possession of the ball as Cheney’s Oliver Smith went to the ground, injured.

Customary in soccer is that when an opposing player is hurt, instead of a team trying to move the ball up and attack with a player advantage, it simply kicks the ball out of bounds to stop play so the player can be tended to – which Tyee did.

Reciprocating, once the player’s injury is handled, his or her team either throws the ball in (if it is close to the opposing goalkeeper) or kicks it down the field to the opposing goalkeeper so play can restart with the rightful team in possession of the ball.

Nowhere is this custom written in any rule book, coaches say.

“But it is seen as honorable,” said Randy Hanson, women’s soccer coach at the University of Puget Sound.

A few Cheney players appeared to know the “unwritten rule,” because after a Blackhawks’ throw-in when play resumed, Cheney defender Andrew Horton booted the ball down the field from near his own goal to where Tyee goalkeeper Alan Mora was waiting to collect it, and send it out to teammates.

About that time, Cheney forward Micah Weller came running up, and decided to make a play on the soccer ball. According to game reports, Weller’s teammates shouted not to touch the ball – to no avail. Weller took possession and beat Mora on a 15-yard shot for the Blackhawks’ first goal.

The match was tied 1-1 heading into halftime – one that saw Tyee lodge an immediate protest with tournament officials. The protest was denied. No rule was violated.

To hear both sides talk about the incident days later, confusion reigned. The Tyee folks see this as a clear violation of sportsmanship, and harbor high-charged frustration over the matter. The Cheney folks claim because other in-game variables were occurring at the same time – for example, sideline substitutions – Weller was correct in making a play on a live ball.

Pertinent questions bounce around my mind in this instance: Did Weller – or more importantly should Weller have known the unwritten rule? Was the custom blatantly ignored or disobeyed? Would it have helped if the game referee, or assistant referee (linesman) intervened (or are they even allowed to)? And should have anybody stopped playing on a live ball?

Here is what Terri McMahan, the Highline School District athletic director, had to say Tuesday about the ever-questioned sequence.

“(The play) is not illegal. But it wasn’t sportsmanlike. And you would hope those types of sportsmanlike behaviors would be reciprocated. It was pretty clear we were on our heels, waiting for officials to respond appropriately.

“I would have hoped the official would have held things up.”

Jim Missel, the Cheney High athletic director, did answer his phone Wednesday morning. He also attended the championship match Saturday.

Hesitant to address the matter at first, Missel did after a few minutes. He reiterated that at the time of the goal, a lot of stuff was going on.

“In my opinion, I saw kids who did not know what was transpiring at the time – on both sides,” Missel said.

Over the past couple of days, Missel said he and the Cheney coaching staff had started to become aware of the backlash over the goal. One athletic director from Pierce County even emailed Missel to lecture him about Cheney soccer coach Mark Kiver’s lack of attention to soccer rules and customs.

“I didn’t realize how much this was going to cause an issue,” Missel said. “I was totally surprised.”

As far as the goal-scorer himself – Weller – by all accounts, he is a model, upstanding leader and team captain. Missel said after the team bus pulled into town early Sunday, Weller volunteered to clean it out before it was transported back to the depot.

“He is a class-act kid,” Missel said.

Bottom line, Tyee wasn’t cheated out of a state title – who knows how this match would have played out if Weller’s goal was disallowed. But the team is right in feeling as if a piece of the sport’s integrity was seriously compromised at its expense.

As far as Cheney, today it still stands as 2A boys soccer champion. Is the crown tainted? Maybe – and even Kiver conceded as much, telling a reporter after the match an “asterisk” might go next to the end result. To label the Blackhawks as cheaters just isn’t fair. But in an era when the WIAA constantly preaches game sportsmanship – “Just Play Fair” – they just perhaps missed out on doing the right thing.

Leave a comment Comments → 6
  1. davidhh says:

    Your article could clarify one important point for your readers. YOu say “Blackhawks defender Andrew Horton booted the ball down the field from near the Cheney goal to where Tyee goalkeeper Alan Mora was waiting to collect it, and send it out to teammates” Was this after the Cheney defender fell to the ground, or after play was restarted? Had Tyee kicked the ball out of bounds, as is customary, so the injured player could receive attention? Or was Cheney simply trying to clear the ball?

  2. The reaction people have been having and that attacks against the cheney boys soccer club are astonishing! They played hard and deserved the win. If Tyee had tried as hard as the cheney team they WOULD HAVE WON. Stop complaining and if you cant SUCK AN EGG.

  3. commoncents says:

    David – the ball was deliberately played out by Tyee so that the injured Cheney player could be attended to. Ensuing throw-in went to Cheney player who (rightly so) tried to knock the ball to the Tyee keeper to fairly place the ball back in the hands of Tyee. Cheney player either didn’t know about this unwritten rule, had forgotten how the ball was played out to begin with, or willingly disregarded it (hey, it’s state playoffs!!!) intercepted that ball and scored. Only the player knows for sure.

    Tygus – The correct fix here lay on the shoulders of the Cheney coach because no rule was broken the refs had their hands tied. Cheney should have allowed Tyee to score unimpeded. Didn’t happen. Keep in mind that Cheney scored their final goal in overtime – a time that never should have occurred had the unwritten rule not been broken. In this aspect though, Todd Milles, is correct…who knows what would have happened if Cheney would have allowed the score or the refs would have interfered? Perhaps Cheney would have fought even harder and scored multiple times in the last few minutes. We don’t know and can’t say, but we do know that sportsmanship and the unwritten codes followed by athletes took a hit in that game.

  4. jboard1 says:

    I’m not a big soccer buff, but if this is such a big deal, why is it an unwritten rule? Why dont they make it an actual “in the book rule”. IMO, if its not a real rule, play on.

  5. Pwhgolf says:

    Thank you Todd for this article. @ Tygust, I’m not sure if you were at the game or not, but Cheney’s goal in the first half was the only shot on goal they had in the entire regulation period. They were soundly beaten by Tyee.

  6. touchdowng says:

    About 8 years ago Bellevue HS was to play Kennedy HS for a big football game. I think it was a finals or semi finals for 3A. The week of the game, Bellevue wasn’t able to hold a couple of practices due to snow and school cancellation. Guess what the coach for Kennedy did? He made the intentional decision of not practicing on those same days as Bellevue because he didn’t want to take advantage of having more prep time due to the circumstances. That’s called sportsmanship and we need to have more of this in prep sports.

    The ball that was intentionally played out of bounds was almost a like gesture on the part of the Tyee player. A Cheney player was down and there was a 10-11 disadvantage for Cheney. It’s a tit for tat situation. Cheney took advantage of this and used it to win the game. Shame on them and shame on their coach for not doing more to recognize and correct this when he could have.

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0