Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

Tag: McNeil Island

Dec.
8th

Lakewood is no place for sex predators

This editorial will appear in Sunday’s print edition.

Folks in Olympia may be soon looking for a new community to host 300 violent sexual psychopaths. Lakewood, call your home security service.

Those predators are now housed and supposedly getting treated at the Special Commitment Center on McNeil Island. They are the worst of the worst – a small fraction of the state’s sex offenders.

They wind up at the SCC only if a court has concluded that they have committed a violent sex crime and suffer from “a mental abnormality” that hinders their control of sexual violence and are “more likely than not to engage in predatory acts of violence again.”

There’s a reason they confined to an island surrounded by deep, frigid water.

The Legislature now faces intense financial pressure to move them to the mainland. The SCC began to look like an extravagance last year, when the state shut down the regular prison on McNeil Island. The prison had shared some of the Special Commitment Center’s costs, an arrangement that originally made a good argument for the location.

Now the SCC is sitting out there by itself with an annual budget of more than $30 million a year. A large chunk of that, $6.6 million, results from the island location. The center also needs repairs and improvements – an estimated $12.2 million worth of work in the 2013-2015 biennium.

Most lawmakers would dearly love to divert that money to their pet projects.
Read more »

Feb.
5th

Don’t waste state funds on predators’ ‘blank check’ defense

This editorial will appear in Monday’s print edition.

As state lawmakers grapple with how to close a $1 billion-plus budget gap, one place they’ve been looking for savings is the Special Commitment Center for violent sex predators on McNeil Island.

Some legislators want to save money by moving the SCC to a mainland site, cutting out the extra expense involved with ferrying to and from the island. But no community is clamoring to host 284 dangerous sex predators, and even if an existing facility could be found it likely would require expensive renovation and security upgrades.

A recent Seattle Times series suggests another strategy: Target the wasteful, uncontrolled legal costs associated with sex offenders either trying to avoid civil commitment to the SCC or to be released if they’re already there.
Read more »

Nov.
28th

There’s a high price to be paid for moving SCC from McNeil

This editorial will appear in Tuesday’s print edition.

Some lawmakers are considering whether to move the Special Commitment Center for violent sex offenders off McNeil Island as a way to help close the state’s $2 billion-plus budget gap. It has become more expensive to run since closure of the state prison on the island.

The only two choices for relocation being discussed, according to a report Sunday by The News Tribune’s Jordan Schrader, are Western State Hospital in Lakewood and the shuttered Maple Lane School in Ground Mound near Centralia.

Lawmakers should consider a few facts about those locations that make it hard to see where short-term savings could be made – and short-term is what the state needs right now.

Consider:
Read more »

Sep.
23rd

SCC’s time running out on McNeil Island?

State Rep. Ross Hunter, D-Bellevue, visited recently to talk about the most recent revenue forecast (a shortfall of $1.2 billion to $2 billion) and provide some background on what can and can’t be cut when the Legislature goes into special session in November.

As chairman of the Ways and Means Committee, Hunter is one of the Legislature’s main budget writers. So it’s worth mentioning that he said one revenue saver would be to move the Special Commitment Center for violent sex offenders off McNeil Island.

That’s been discussed before, but now seems all but inevitable with the closure of

Read more »

March
8th

Resist these temptations, lawmakers

This editorial will appear in tomorrow’s print edition.

Of the hundred-odd foolish things that might yet come out of Olympia this winter, three stand out:

Raise the sales tax

Some new taxes appear necessary to save fundamentally important state programs, such as compensatory funding for property-poor school districts and financial aid for college students with low incomes.

It now seems too much to expect that the Democrats who control both House and Senate will squeeze more out of their core constituents – for example, by reopening state workers’ contracts, canceling scheduled raises and requiring them to pay what their

Read more »

March
1st

Good reason to be wary of McNeil closure

This editorial will appear in Tuesday’s print edition.

State lawmakers should take a hard look at how much closing McNeil Island Corrections Center would actually save the state. South Sound legislators ought to also keep in mind what the closure could ultimately cost this community.

On Saturday, the state Senate set the stage for a showdown by passing a budget that calls for the McNeil prison’s closure in exchange for keeping a Vancouver prison open. (The House favors reducing the island’s 1,200-inmate population by half instead.)

Members of the Senate have been trying for years to get the state to study closing the McNeil prison, which is expensive to operate due to its remote location. People and supplies have to be ferried to and from the island, which has its own ferry service, fire department and wastewater treatment plant.

The Legislature finally commissioned that study last year – but the report doesn’t seem to have told senators what they wanted to hear.
Read more »

Oct.
1st

Who’s bringing the ‘candy’ into the Special Commitment Center?

Consider the source, but we’ve gotten several letters from sexual predators at the McNeil Island Special Commitment Center who insist that child pornography is getting into the place through staff members. (Seven of the center’s sex offenders were recently indicted for possessing child porn.)

One writes:

For the past four years I have been at the center, all of our incoming mail is first X-rayed, then is checked closely by the SCC mailroom staff when residents open their mail. Pictures that come in from our family and friends are looked at closely before we are allowed to have them.

Read more »

Sep.
17th

Strange but true: Child porn on McNeil Island

This editorial will appear in tomorrow’s print edition.

One of the seven sex offenders busted for child porn Thursday at the Special Commitment Center had been twice convicted of child rape.

Another of sexual assault, indecent liberties and communicating with a minor for immoral purposes.

Another of lewd and lascivious acts toward a minor, contributing to the delinquency of a minor and indecent liberties.

You get the idea.

Ordinary sex offenders don’t wind up in the center on McNeil Island. They constitute a tiny fraction of all such criminals. They must have proven themselves to be compulsive career predators. They must clear the high legal hurdle for commitment: a formal court finding that they continue to pose a dire threat to society as “sexually violent predators.”
Read more »