Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

He said, she said

Post by Maggie McGuire on Nov. 12, 2011 at 11:11 am with 1 Comment »
November 12, 2011 11:11 am

This business with Herman Cain and workplace sexual harassment allegations against him sparked a memory from almost thirty years ago. It didn’t happen in a car, it wasn’t at night, there had been no drinks and dinner, and there was no physical groping.

Was it inappropriate? You be the judge.

It was 1983. I was in my early thirties. I’d applied for a position with a major employer, and was in the final phase of the hiring process. I’d already survived a panel interview, a presentation to demonstrate my skills, a self-assessment exercise in others’ presence, and reference checking. The final step was a one-on-one interview with the hiring manager, the person to whom I would report.

Things went fine until he began inquiring about my personal life. There was no one else present.

“I understand that this is your second marriage, and that you went through a tough time a few years ago.” “Yes,” I responded, “my first husband and I divorced shortly after my last year teaching at the university. But my professional performance was not affected. In fact, I received the highest instructional ratings of all faculty in my department.”


“What were the problems in your marriage? Why did it end?”

Red lights began to strobe in my head. “Who IS this guy,” I thought, “and exactly what do my first marriage and its dissolution have to do with my qualifications for this position?”

I paused, thought carefully about what I would say, trusted my gut, and finally offered some bland response about growing apart, being too young. The subject changed and there were no further questions about this topic.

I wanted that job. I knew I was more than qualified, even though I also knew that what he was asking was prurient and out of line. The company was big and new to me and I didn’t know whom to tell. What I did know was that I felt extremely uncomfortable, and that a boundary had been crossed. I also knew that, if I had complained at that point, I probably would not have been hired. I had absolutely no reputation or influence yet in the company. I would have been a nobody, complaining about an established manager.

I got the job and reported to this individual for five years. And, I remained on alert.

Distance–personal and physical–worked for me. I rarely was alone with him, except for the annual performance review discussion. I revealed little about myself and always kept conversations professional. This is not my usual style, but my gut alert dial with this person never moved off “red.”

He was terminated in my fifth year. A series of complaints, from within and outside our team, to Human Resources about his hostile work environment got company leadership’s attention and sealed his fate. The system worked. I went on to a rewarding twenty more years there.

The women who have filed complaints against Herman Cain may have felt the same disbelief, powerlessness and isolation that I did at first thirty years ago. Circumstances can prevent a voice from being heard immediately. What’s important is that it’s heard…finally.

Leave a comment Comments → 1
  1. Really that’s what bothers you, so without corroboration, without proof (the settlements prove nothing)they could have settled to put it behind them, it would have cost more to litigate, prove it. Your willing to destroy a man without proof but when faced with overwhelming proof you give a man a pass. At least be consistent or shut up…

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0