Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

Repeal ‘Obamacare’? Show us the alternative

Post by Patrick O'Callahan on Jan. 18, 2011 at 7:54 pm with 2 Comments »
January 18, 2011 5:57 pm

This editorial will appear in tomorrow’s print edition.

OK, Republicans, let’s see your health care bill.

The new GOP majority in the U.S. House of Representatives is poised today to repeal last year’s Affordable Care Act (or “Obamacare” – take your pick). It’s an empty gesture as far as lawmaking goes: The Democratic majority in the Senate won’t second the motion, and President Obama certainly wouldn’t sign a repeal of his signature legislation.

But Republicans hope to follow up with piecemeal attacks on the 2010 package that might eventually gut it. The fattest target is the law’s requirement that most Americans carry health insurance. It’s unpopular; it’s also a way to prevent freeloaders from buying insurance after they get sick, then dropping it as soon as they’ve had their babies or their hip replacements.

The Affordable Care Act promises to do the job of extending medical coverage to most Americans, but it is not a work of art. A repeal would be fantastic – if the law were being replaced with something better. The problem is, congressional Republicans aren’t offering a better bill. In fact, they’re offering no bill at all.

They do have ideas, and some of them could be good if done right. They include more tax credits to help Americans buy medical coverage; tighter limits on lawsuits against doctors and other providers; less expensive policies with stripped-down, basic benefits, and health savings accounts that encourage people to sock away their own money to pay for future care.

Ideas are not bills, though. One virtue of the Affordable Care Act is that it is real. Its price has been vetted by the Congressional Budget Office, and its warts and dimples are out there for the world to see. That beats vague talk about malpractice costs and the free market.

There’s a problem with the “market-based” solutions many Republicans tout: America hasn’t had a genuine free market in health care for more than a half-century, and the damage has long since been done.

Since the 1940s, when the U.S. government offered huge tax incentives for employer-based insurance, most Americans have been insulated from the actual price of their own care. The system has invited overuse.

In the 1960s, Medicare made the insulation thicker for patients and doctors alike. For many years, the program simply wrote checks on demand, which escalated costs and encouraged expensive, procedure-intensive medicine. There’s no getting back to the days of the $5 house call.

Given that reality, it’s hard to see how the working poor can get coverage without subsidies and mandates. Health savings accounts, for example, work only if you’ve got serious money to sock away in them.

If the congressional Republicans have a rabbit hidden in their hat, now’s the time to pull it out. We’d love to get a look at their real-world alternative to the Affordable Care Act.

Leave a comment Comments → 2
  1. Thank you for well thought out and fact based editorial. Health care reform done in the last congress is a good start but is certainly not perfect. So wouldn’t this congress make a better use of their time trying to improve what we have so far then starting from square one? Some things do need to be fixed like the 1099 issue for small and medium sized business, something this congress could and should be working on, not repeal. There are many good parts of health care reform that is just starting to be implemented like keeping your adult children on your insurance till they are 26, no longer denying insurance for children who have pre-existing conditions, tax credits for small business to help them buy insurance, and no lifetime cap on your insurance. This is just so far, by 2014 we will have insurance exchanges where we everyone who have a health insurance need can purchase a plan right for them (even across state lines) as those who have a group plan available to them can do now. Also by 2014 the exclusions for a pre-existing condition for adults will be gone. Bottom line maybe we can stem the tide of people coming to the emergency rooms for basic health care. And if someone does have a real emergency they will be covered so everyone else will not have to pick up the tab.

  2. plain_old_Dave says:

    The Republicans have no alternative to this Act, and everyone knows it.

    And please don’t confuse anyone with the facts.

    Something else which is no secret is that the Republicans are in the pocket of the insurance companies and big pharma, and their noise machine has generated enough propaganda to get folks who already “have theirs” to lend their voices to their manufactured chorus of negativity.

    The country is being run for the rich, by the rich, and to hell with everone else. And those who have “got theirs” for now may well sing a different tune when they finally realize they participated in screwing themselves.

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0