Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

In Seattle, terror drives the First Amendment underground

Post by Patrick O'Callahan on Sep. 16, 2010 at 7:46 pm with 3 Comments »
September 16, 2010 6:21 pm

This editorial will appear in tomorrow’s print edition.

Terrorist intimidation has just cost a Seattle cartoonist her freedom. Her crime: exercising her First Amendment rights.

That’s Seattle, as in the United States. There doesn’t seem to be a Seattle in Yemen.

Molly Norris, whose work appears in the Seattle Weekly, gained international attention last spring after she drew a mock promotion of an imaginary event, “Everbody Draw Mohammed Day.” The spoof poster, published on Facebook, depicted various inanimate objects – including a coffee cup and a domino – each claiming to be the true likeness of the founder of Islam.

Norris drew it as a satirical comment on Comedy Central’s censorship of two South Park episodes in which cartoon characters refer to another character – inside a bear costume – as Muhammad. Comedy Central backed away from those episodes because of death threats from radical Muslims.

The poster proposed “Draw Mohammed Day” to – in its own words – “defend a little something our country is famous for … the First Amendment.”

Taken seriously by many, the fictitious event went viral. Pakistan – one of the world’s largest countries – has responded by shutting down Facebook within its borders. Anwar al-Awlaki, a fugitive U.S.-born cleric, has issued a fatwa calling for Norris’ death.

Some fatwas are more to be feared than others. This one is apparently much to be feared. The Seattle Weekly’s editor-in-chief, Mark Fefer, wrote Wednesday that “Molly Norris’ comic is not in the paper this week. That’s because there is no more Molly.”

To protect Norris from what it considers a serious threat to her life, the FBI advised her go into hiding and establish a new identity for herself.

People have been arguing about Norris’ cartoon poster for months, just as people argued recently about a jackleg Florida preacher’s “International Burn a Quran Day.”

Norris said she didn’t intend to create an actual “Draw Mohammed Day,” but a lot of people celebrated the idea. It’s reasonable to suggest that Americans shouldn’t be going out of their way to offend the sensibilities of Muslims, many of whom regard drawings of Muhammad as sacrilegious.

But that conversation is beside the point when an American living in America is forced into hiding by homicidal fanatics who are willing to murder a woman over a gently satirical drawing.

In 1954, when his colleagues were fretting about whether to air a show attacking Joe McCarthy, Edward R. Murrow famously said it must be broadcast because “the terror is right here in this room.”

When a terrorist fatwa from Yemen can force a Seattle cartoonist into run for her life, the terror feels way too close to home.

Leave a comment Comments → 3
  1. Nothing peaceful about Islam and it’s followers. The number of moderate Muslims would fit into a mini van with room for Porky Pig and his family.

  2. I’ve been reading the 36 articles in the charter of (Muslim Brotherhood) Hamas.
    I’ve also been studying the Wahhab / House of Saud history and the content curriculum of Saudi sponsored madrasas. If we could please put away the TV remote, I-Pod and text-messaging apparatus for a moment or two and just brush up a little on what Islam says of itself, and who in our own government
    (John Brennan- Homeland “security”) is making speeches in Arabic that he does not want known or reported on in English (from a speech at N.Y.University in February) , we would all understand a LOT more of the why and who of current policy regarding the “religion of peace”…

  3. icedoggie says:

    I am sorry Molly Norris for what you have and are going through. It is small consolation that you are neither the first nor undoubtedly the last to suffer this or greater loss.

    This is I believe still America and it should not happen here………this intimidation is far beyond an outrage……Molly’s right is fundamental to our existence and it is our responsibility as Americans to uphold her right.

    Short of a full reformation in the world of Islam, I can only hope that our soldier’s rounds and our Predator missiles swiftly and accurately lay inert their intended targets.

    My other hope is that we as a free people do not lose our grip on the will to confront evil.

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0