Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

Immigrant license surge argues for two-tier system

Post by Kim Bradford on Aug. 16, 2010 at 6:37 pm with 3 Comments »
August 16, 2010 5:40 pm

This editorial will appear in Tuesday’s print edition.

What happens in Arizona doesn’t stay in Arizona.

That’s the conclusion some experts draw from the exploding number of immigrants seeking driver’s licenses in three states.

Washington, Utah and New Mexico are the only states in the nation that permit illegal immigrants to get licenses. All three are seeing a big surge in the wake of Arizona’s crackdown on illegal immigration.

Reporters for The Associated Press found one of the Arizona exiles just north of here, in Burien. Carlos Hernandez packed up his whole family after Arizona passed its new law and came to Washington. He cited access to identification as a key reason.

What’s more, crooks are making a lot of money exploiting the already loose rules.

In June, the FBI arrested three people – two of them Department of Licensing employees – for schemes to sell driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants. One suspect was allegedly charging as much as $3,000 a person to supply an address to use during the license-application process, the answers to the written driver’s test and the inside track on license approval.

The danger is not that illegal immigrants are getting driver’s licenses. The danger is that they are using those licenses for a lot more than driving. A driver’s license will get someone on an airplane. A license and a fake Social Security card will get them a job.

The best answer is secure driver’s licenses, the kind envisioned by the REAL ID Act passed in the wake of 9/11. It would require states to verify legal status before issuing licenses.
But the law, which originally was bogged down by states’ concerns over costs, faces an uncertain future: President Obama nominated one of its foes, Janet Napolitano, to head Homeland Security. She’s pushed back the deadline to comply.

But even if REAL ID were in force in all 50 states today, many of this country’s 12 million undocumented immigrants would remain behind the wheel.

States face the real-world problem of how best to protect the public. Driver’s licenses provide access to liability insurance and some modicum of assurance that the holder knows the rules of the road.

More states may need to adopt a two-tier approach similar to Utah’s. There, drivers who cannot prove their legal status are issued a “driving privilege card,” which permits them access to the roads but cannot be used as identification – not even to buy beer.

Utah’s card has proved popular. The state handed out nearly 44,000 of them in 2008 – and is on pace to issue twice as many this year since it, like Washington, is getting bombarded with immigrants fleeing crackdowns elsewhere.

Apparently, not all illegal immigrants seek drivers’ licenses to game the system. Some really do just want to drive legally. It’s ultimately in a state’s best interests to ensure they can.

Leave a comment Comments → 3
  1. lovethemountains says:

    “It’s ultimately in the state’s best interests to ensure they can.”

    Only if the motor vehicle insurance requirements are re-visited to ensure legal and law abiding citizen’s interests are protected first. Along with driving while impaired the insurance requirements need to be more strict with increased enforcement. Driving while impaired and driving without insurance should result in impoundment (and seizure upon a second offense) of the offender’s vehicles, to be returned only after proof of insurance and, in the case of driving while impaired, more vigorous penalties and mandatory and extensive behavior modification.

    I am sick and tired of drunk drivers being handed a slap on the wrist even after multiple convictions. And I am equally tired of increased insurance premiums for coverage for my loss at the hands of those who choose not to purchase insurance.

    What is wrong with our society that we look so casually at death on the highways that are the result of being impaired by the ingestion of alcohol or drugs. We also seem to look at those who victimize us by not being responsible enough to cover their accidents in an equally casual manner.

  2. Sanctuary State policy is replicated at county and city levels and it is a disgusting example of political-correctness and a self addicted legislature. As a recovering target of vehicular assault by an illegal alien (legal term here) the political effects of my car accident are outweighing the physical ones which included 3 surgeries and all new teeth except three. After being off work for over 8 months I found what hurt much more was the attitude of the KENT police department’s failure to actually check (call the 1-800 #) on the illegal’s so-called “proof-of-insurance” card. The I.D / photo-shop business is thriving while the KENT police and others play dumb by “just following orders”.
    Thanks Christine, and courts and legislature for protecting the citizens of WA State…..and KENT police…..thanks for nothing…

  3. Though I don’t have as much to say, I too understand the frustration they may feel. I’m 16, and although I don’t yet have my license, illegal immigrants wrecking havoc on our roads is a set up for a war amongst angry annoyed citizens, immigrants, and the police. Police “just following” orders will lead to the wrongful ownership of lisences that are possessed by these immigrants, to possibly cause drunk accidents (or just any accidents caused by poor driving) to anger American citizens. It’s a set up for disaster in my eyes.

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0