Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

Memo to Teamsters: Park volunteers aren’t scabs

Post by Patrick O'Callahan on July 29, 2010 at 7:46 pm with 7 Comments »
July 29, 2010 5:49 pm

This editorial will appear in tomorrow’s print edition.

Teamsters Local Union 117, which represents Pierce County’s park maintenance workers, knows one set of rules by heart.

If its leaders think the county is breaking those rules, they know the drill: Parse their contract language. File grievances. Feed unfair labor practices claims into the machinery of the state Public Employment Relations Commission.

They did that this month over perceived contract violations by Pierce County Parks & Recreation.

But there’s a bigger set of rules that involve public goodwill and the devotion of volunteers. The union trampled those rules when it decided to fight the efforts of neighbors who stepped forward to clean up and maintain the Gonyea and Dawson playfields in Parkland and Midland.

Those two parks – and many others – had been all but abandoned by Pierce County as a result of its dire financial crisis. Funding has gotten scarce, and Parks & Recreation has been forced to stop watering grass, picking up trash and operating restrooms at many of its properties.

The neighbors weren’t content to stand by and watch their playfields rot. They took on some of the maintenance work on their own initiative. The Teamsters raised a stink: The work belonged to them, and Parks & Recreation was letting volunteers do it for free.

If the county were awash in money, the complaint might make sense. But Parks & Recreation is barely breathing financially, and the $80,000 the County Council has now allocated to keep Gonyea and Dawson open would be far better spent on properties where neighborhood intervention wasn’t feasible.

The Teamsters may prevail with PERC, but they’ve made themselves look grasping and petty in the eyes of the taxpayers who pay their salaries. Smart generals pick their battles carefully; this was one the union’s leaders shouldn’t have fought.

It makes no sense to treat volunteers like scabs, especially in the middle of a recession that has squeezed public services so severely. One thing that distinguishes the United States from many other countries is the willingness of its citizens to improve their communities without any expectation of payment.

Parks, especially, have long relied on the enthusiasm and devotion of people who love them.

Such events as Parks Appreciation Day, National Trails Day and Washington Coastal Cleanups demonstrate the willingness of citizens to pick up trash, cut down blackberry thickets, restore streams and build infrastructure. After the devastating floods of late 2006, volunteers were crucial to the reconstruction of Mount Rainier’s trails and campsites.

Unions in general get this: They have a strong ethic of volunteerism themselves. But that fact is lost on the public when a county starts closing parks for lack of money, and a union stands between a playfield and its neighbors.

Leave a comment Comments → 7
  1. Teamsters and Union Brothers: Do yourselves a favor. Shut up.

  2. olympicmtn says:

    If union labor is so great and efficient why did it take a whole week, yes ONE FULL week to paint a classroom in the Tacoma School District. The district was dinged on this a couple years ago. So please don’t talk about efficiency and unions in the same sentence.

  3. nonstopjoe says:

    The volunteers are scabs, plain and simple. The point of volunteerism is to allow recipients to avoid paying because the work done for free. This denies workers the opportunity to earn wages – which is no different than sending jobs overseas.

  4. Patrick,
    You’re off on this one. The issue isn’t volunteers, it’s not union members.

    It’s about communication.

    There is a contract between the employer and the employees. The employer changed the terms of the contract with out going through the proper channels.

    A contract is a contract, and it needs to be respected.

  5. nonstopjoe says:

    I agree that attempting an end run around the K is a big problem. So, let the K run out, don’t attempt to renew it, and establish a non-profit entity of volunteers to do the work – and, if that’s not enough, employ some non-union workers eager for work.

  6. tubbythetuba says:

    A contract is a contract….BUT, it’s the people’s park….The union is wrong on this one.

  7. tubbythetuba says:

    BTW, Pierce County is chip sealing streets again this year. Some of them hardly needed it….what’s up with that? If budget items were not carved in stone, perhaps different priorities could be set as time goes by???

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0