Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

A gifted commander, McChrystal still had to go

Post by Patrick O'Callahan on June 23, 2010 at 7:24 pm with 2 Comments »
June 23, 2010 5:27 pm

This editorial will appear in tomorrow’s print edition.

Relieving a capable commander in the middle of a war is a high-risk move. In the case of Gen. Stanley McChrystal, it’s a risk Barack Obama had to take.

Until this week, McChrystal looked like America’s best bet to hold the Taliban at bay and buy Afghanistan’s weak government enough time to secure the country.

American troops have been complaining about the civilian-friendly rules of engagement he has imposed, but McChrystal understands a fundamental truth: The Taliban cannot be defeated unless the Afghan population turns against them. Protecting civilians – from the Taliban, but also from American bombs and bullets – is the only way this can happen.

McChrystal is the architect of NATO’s strategy in Afghanistan, which has much in common with the strategy Gen. David Petraeus successfully used to turn around the war in Iraq.

Afghanistan and Iraq are very different countries, and there’s not the least guarantee that McChrystal’s plan can replicate Petraeus’ success in Iraq. But despite the recent spike in U.S. casualties, pessimism is also premature.

Casualties also spiked in the early months of the “surge” in Iraq, chiefly because the insurgents were being challenged far more aggressively for permanent control of the streets. The Obama-McChrystal build-up in Afghanistan can’t be judged this early – especially since U.S. troops won’t be at full strength until end of the summer.

But McChrystal himself can’t stay. He is too smart and too politically savvy not to be held accountable for the insolent remarks he and his staff recently made in front of a Rolling Stone reporter – who predictably featured them in a lengthy profile of the general.

Some things you can say to confidants, but not in the hearing of someone you know will likely broadcast them to an international audience.

McChrystal and his staff – who style themselves as Team America – are human. Like anyone else, they will gripe among themselves about their superiors and mock people they disagree with. But McChrystal foolishly let his frustration with Obama and Vice President Joe Biden go public by letting his staff dish about them to Rolling Stone, to the point of conveying his reported impressions that the president was unengaged and intimidated by military commanders.

This doesn’t rise to the level of Douglas MacArthur openly defying the wartime leadership of Harry Truman, but it involves the same bedrock constitutional principle of civilian control of the military. Obama would have looked gutless had he let McChrystal’s remarks pass. In wartime, a commander-in-chief does not have the option of looking gutless.

Fortunately a replacement for McChrystal was close at hand: Petraeus. For all McChrystal’s virtues, this looks like trade up.

Leave a comment Comments → 2
  1. Novelist3 says:

    “it’s a risk Barack Obama had to take”

    Sure, Mr. News Tribune. Can’t have anyone in power who actually reflects what the reality of public opinion towards this failed presdident is. Gotta make sure he surrounds himself with sycophantic yes-men who will simply smile and nod at every ridiculous thing he does! God, I can’t wait for November.

  2. I personally like the “Leonidas / Alexander – 2012″ ticket, oh and BTW , a good CIC (pronounced ‘sick’) would have a concentric defense posture for lateral, van, and rear-guard, which the current lad does not. He’s too busy listening to Mc Artney ( Lennon’s spelling) while playing the Tiger (don’t hit me with my own club, honey) game. His sick idea of “victory” (an archaic foreign term) is a bureaucratic monarchy. Please call his Labor Secretary, Hilda Solis at 1866-487-9243 to see his opinion of YOU vs. ILLEGAL immigrants as he boycotts our front-line state…

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0