Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

The mystery of Wall Street’s stampeding market

Post by Patrick O'Callahan on May 9, 2010 at 6:26 pm with 7 Comments »
May 7, 2010 6:29 pm

This editorial will appear in tomorrow’s print edition.

Start with the obvious: Some mysterious gremlin in some murky nook of America’s trading system should not be able to trigger the steepest sell-off in Wall Street history.

For that matter, a small Mediterranean country’s bad debts should not be able to threaten the European economy and spook investors around the world.

And while we’re on the subject, incomprehensible financial products based on fraudulent mortgage schemes should not be able to throw the world into a near-catastrophic credit crisis, as happened in 2008.

Republicans in Congress are attempting a last stand against a Democratic package of sweeping new regulations on financial markets and institutions. The Republicans make the usual points – some of them valid – about the virtues of free markets and the burdens of government restriction. But they’re shouting into a gale.

Americans have seen hundreds of billions of their dollars used to bail out enormous banks, and they aren’t in a mood to let the markets regulate themselves.

The nation overreacts in one direction, then overreacts in the opposite direction. Congress will no doubt loosen some restrictions when it becomes clear which do more harm then good. But right now public sympathy for Wall Street’s wheelers and dealers is running about as low as it was in 1934.

Fortunately, the debacle in Greece has tempered recent enthusiasm for heavy government spending; it’s also quieted the neo-socialists who’d begun sticking their heads up again in hopes that the world had turned their way. The logical alternative to an economy ruled by robber barons is not an economy staggering under ruinous, unsustainable social welfare spending.

Economic theories apparently had nothing to do with Thursday’s brief but terrifying plunge. The likely culprit is some combination of technical flukes, including a possible disconnect between the protocols of different exchanges, or even a typographical mistake. Whatever it was triggered a software-driven frenzy of stock sales.

It’s scary that the geniuses who oversee the trading system couldn’t immediately diagnose the problem, which suggests that we’ve created an electronic monster we do not fully understand or control. The synthetic panic points to an unsuspected vulnerability in America’s financial markets, which amounts to a hole in the nation’s security.

This is the stuff of fantasy thrillers; it shouldn’t happen in real life.

When it comes to markets, Roosevelt was right: The worst nightmare is fear itself. Investors don’t merely react to events; they react to how they think others will react. The psychology of collective panic can magnify bad news a thousand-fold.

On Friday, the gremlin in the system had vanished, European leaders were moving decisively to contain the damage from Greece, and the U.S. government announced surprisingly strong job growth. The markets still fell. We hope this week will be a different story.

Leave a comment Comments → 7
  1. witchiwoman says:

    The free market is extinct, in case anybody is wondering. Day traders have turned the stock market into a roulette wheel, spinning, spinning…….”The only way to win is NOT to play the game…..”

  2. larsman says:

    Patrick, I’m surprised that you seem to be blaming this or that ‘party’. The Community Re-investment Act (Jimmy Carter, btw), Fannie-Freddie et al seemed to accelerate the greed/speed cycle of the revolving door of lobbyist today , elected official tomorrow, Goldman Sachs broker next session( same person, different times, different hats ). Frank, Paulsen and Dodd should be placed before a ‘financial tribunal’ for lying about the status of derivative loans
    underwritten, unwillingly, be me the taxpayer.When I hear quotes like “We need to do this or that”, what is meant by “we” specifically? Is that like a mouse in Leonard Pitt’s shirt pocket (he likes making statements in the 2nd person which is grammatically disingenuous). Maybe it’s time for Alexander to slice this knot.

  3. fatuous says:

    “The likely culprit is some combination of technical flukes, including a possible disconnect between the protocols of different exchanges, or even a typographical mistake.”

    I doubt it!

    It’s more likely computer programs based on differential equations some math geeks wrote.

    Buy or sell orders are then executed by computers based on the results the differential equations spit out.

    “For that matter, a small Mediterranean country’s bad debts should not be able to threaten the European economy and spook investors around the world.”

    It’s not just Greece. It’s Spain, Italy, Ireland, and Portugal too, not to mention Great Britain, Japan, USA, and the other smaller players.

  4. nascar9 says:

    witchiwoman, The free market is not extinct. You just have to do your homework and buy good stocks and keep an eye on them, and learn not to be afraid of a few ups and downs. Day traders will only hurt you if you let them.

  5. coldone says:

    Republicans in Congress?
    I thought this whole mess was created by Democrats in Congress trying to make it easier for lower income people to buy houses?
    Now they are trying to dig themselves out of the mess they created by going overboard on more regulation.

    I’ve never understood why “the stock market” isn’t reguired to have a gaming license. All it is is people betting against each other while Wall Street takes a
    cut, commissions, to keep track of the scam. Sorry about that. I mean investments!

  6. fatuous says:

    I thought this whole mess was created by Democrats in Congress trying to make it easier for lower income people to buy houses?

    Well you thought wrong. And even if it were true and it isn’t, what in the heck did the Republicans, who where in charge. do about it?

    Answer: the Republicans did nothing. Why because Wall Street was making money, and when Wall Street tells Congress to jump, Congress asks how high.

  7. Les similaires le magazine de solidarit� dans les surtout plus de b�n�fice. L’origine le r�flexe que la mission de chaque pour appliquer votre r�duction. La code de promotion une news des conna�tre son refus.

*
We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0