Inside Opinion

What's on the minds of Tacoma News Tribune editorial writers

NOTICE: Inside Opinion has moved.

With the launch of our new website, we've moved Inside Opinion.
Visit the new section.

More can be less with police memorial processions

Post by Patrick O'Callahan on Nov. 11, 2009 at 7:55 pm with 5 Comments »
November 11, 2009 5:36 pm

This editorial will appear in tomorrow’s print edition.

This may be the least popular question we raise all year, but here goes:
Might a fallen police officer be properly honored without a miles-long memorial procession of so many squad cars it ties up major city arterials for hours?

Seattle Officer Timothy Brenton, who was shot to death a week ago Saturday by a mad dog killer, deserved the high honors he received Friday. He deserved the personal tributes, the honor guard, the 21-gun salute, the memorial service at KeyArena. When law enforcement officers take bullets for the rest of us, they and their profession ought to be recognized.

It is possible to take good things too far. We respectfully suggest that what has become a tradition of incredibly lengthy street processions for both law-enforcement officers and firefighters has crossed the line.

In Brenton’s case, the City of Seattle hosted thousands of police officers and firefighters from across Washington, and from Canada, Idaho, Oregon and California. Many drove their official vehicles on a processional route that ran from Husky Stadium to KeyArena by way of Montlake Boulevard, Denny Way and other major thoroughfares. Apparently this had to be done on a weekday. People who normally use those busy streets were warned to avoid them from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m.

It is hard to miss the contrast between this public spectacle and the solemn – but far more intimate – honors bestowed on Fort Lewis soldiers killed in the line of duty in Afghanistan and Iraq.

On Tuesday, for example, services were held in the North Fort Chapel for seven Stryker brigade members who were killed in Afghanistan two weeks ago by a single bomb. Because of the magnitude of the loss, the memorial drew members of Congress, generals, even Vice President Joe Biden.

Noticeably missing was anything like the immense procession of vehicles staged in Seattle Friday. The U.S. Army is not short of vehicles. By the logic that prevails in some police and firefighter memorials, the death of seven Stryker soldiers would have warranted several miles of Humvees and Strykers on Interstate 5 during rush hour.

At some point, more is less. Few dare say it out loud, but many citizens undoubtedly resent the takeover of their streets on workdays by officers from distant places who had no personal acquaintance with the fallen. Past a certain size, the memorial procession starts to seem less about honoring the fallen individual and more about calling attention to the profession in general and the risks it faces.

We submit that the public is already well aware of those risks. Brenton’s death, by itself, made the point all too emphatically.

Leave a comment Comments → 5
  1. jimkingjr says:

    Yes, it is ALL about parading the “importance”. I’m all for letting them have miles of parade, if they’ll give up the extraordinary benefits meant to recompense them.

  2. outtahere says:

    When a peace officer is killed in the line of duty we mourn not only his passing but the loss of part of our civilization. He is our representative. When this happens it is essential that every citizen remember that it is not that a man died but that a part of what makes us kind, decent, fair, true and good has been murdered. Personally, I think the processions, the television broadcasts and all the elaborate trappings are vitally important. The “inconvenience” you whine about is another reminder of the coarsening of our society and the lack of respect we have for each other.

  3. I would not deny these public servants this traditional salute to fallen officers, even if it makes you 20 minutes late for your latte or whatever.

  4. diogenes says:

    I posted this comment in the TNT 6 Nov 09:

    diogenes says:
    November 6, 2009 at 12:43 pm
    It is a sad time whenever anyone loses their life prematurely and unnecessarily at the hands of another human being or loses their life in the performance of duties to serve and protect society. It is good and fitting that those who everyday place themselves in harms way for the good of all should be given honor and respect upon their premature passing. But there are others besides just police and fire personnel who also place themselves in harms way on a regular basis for the good of all. I’m beginning to feel the “pomp and circumstance” accorded to the passing of police and fire personnel take away from the honor and respect that should also be accorded to all the others who give their lives for the good of their fellow man and don’t hesitate to act without regard to the possible loss of their own lives when circumstances demand that action be taken. When I think of all who are true heroes and heroines, I don’t limit my list to just the police and fire personnel. Why, as a society, don’t we accord the same level of “pomp and circumstance” to every military service member who places the lives of others above his or her own?

    Now I don’t feel so alone.

  5. redgauntlet says:

    Answer: no.

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0