Letters to the Editor

Your views in 200 words or less

GEORGE WILL: Conservatives reject columnist’s claim

Letter by Glenn P. Sugameli, Washington, D.C. on Sep. 14, 2011 at 12:41 pm with 3 Comments »
September 14, 2011 12:41 pm

Re: “Government shouldn’t so easily erase individual rights” (George Will column, 9-8).

Will ignores a key fact: His claim that the Supreme Court “correctly decided Lochner” in 1905 has been rejected overwhelmingly by conservatives — including by Will himself.

Indeed, the author of the book Will relies on reacted by stressing that “conservative jurists have been, if anything, even more anti–Lochner than their liberal counterparts.” Libertarian professor Don Bordeaux pointed out that conservatives – including Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Scalia – routinely join “Progressives” in bashing Lochner. No less a conservative icon than Robert Bork derides Lochner as being “the symbol, indeed the quintessence, of judicial usurpation of power.”

Finally, as National Review commentator Matthew J. Franck explains: “This is the same George Will who in 1996 described Lochner as standing for the proposition that ‘the court can overturn laws it considers unwise.’”

(Sugameli is staff attorney for the Judging the Environment project and Defenders of Wildlife.)

Tags:
Leave a comment Comments → 3
  1. BlaineCGarver says:

    Lochner is good within the confines of the original scope of the trial: bakers. When stretched too far to cover unintended subjects, it falls flat.

  2. as National Review commentator Matthew J. Franck explains: “This is the same George Will who in 1996 described Lochner as standing for the proposition that ‘the court can overturn laws it considers unwise.’”

    Will is never one to let personal consistency get in the way of a chance to ding liberals..

  3. LarryFine says:

    LOL bB I’ll have to save that one for (no doubt) future use…

*
We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0