Blue Byline

A cop's perspective of the news and South Sound matters

A violent lesson worth passing on

Post by Brian O'Neill on May 7, 2012 at 10:06 am with 6 Comments »
May 7, 2012 3:28 pm

Every now and then a story comes along that grabs your attention. The truly exceptional ones, the tales that resonate on several levels over the span of years, are a rarity. I want to share one that I first heard over twenty years ago, when I was a young man struggling through the process of becoming a police officer. Its lesson has implications well beyond law enforcement, but I’ll warn you now – it’s violent.

It is known as the Newhall Incident and it occurred in 1970 just outside of Los Angeles. The story begins with two career criminals, Jack Twinning and Bobby Davis, who were stopped by two California Highway Patrol Officers, Roger Frago and Walt Gore, for their role in a firearms incident earlier in the day.

The officers approached the car and searched Davis. Twinning then came out of the passenger seat firing, instantly killing Officer Frago. Officer Gore returned fire at Twinning but was killed when he turned his back to Davis. In seconds, two cops were killed.

Two more CHP officers, George Alleyn and James Pence, arrived at that moment to back up their colleagues. Twinning and Davis began firing, and the officers took cover behind their car to return fire. Officer Alleyn quickly emptied his shotgun, switched to his revolver and emptied this as well. He grazed Twinning with a round, but was shot and killed when Davis, knowing the officer was out of ammunition, advanced on him.

Officer Pence likewise emptied his CHP issued revolver without hitting a target. He was then struck three times and fell to the ground. Twinning and Davis continued to advance, having rearmed from their vehicle’s pre-loaded weapons cache. Pence, severely injured, was forced to reload his revolver one round at a time (CHP did not issue speed-loaders which could load all six revolver rounds simultaneously).

Just as Pence loaded the final round, Twinning came up from behind and shot him twice in the head. Investigators later found Pence’s rounds in his front pocket, a habit drilled into CHP officers at the shooting range. It was a training failure that may have cost him his life.

The rest of the story is mere epilogue: Twinning and Davis escaped; Twinning later killed himself while barricaded inside a house; Davis surrendered to police only after running out of ammunition at another traffic stop; he killed himself in prison three years ago.

The death of four police officers in a single violent encounter sent shock waves through the country and propelled major changes in law enforcement tactics and training, especially within the California Highway Patrol. Since then the Newhall Massacre, as it is now known, has been a mainstay of basic academy instruction. I have sat through at least four different training sessions involving this incident learning something new each time.

From a law enforcement standpoint the two basic lessons involve mindset and training. Twinning and Davis won this gun battle as a result of their aggressive advance towards their targets, twice resulting in point blank shootings. Their mobility and constant attack, a result of the numerous firearms at their disposal (which included the CHP officers’ weapons), were decisive. The CHP officers, none of whom were over 24 years of age or with more than 2 years of experience, relied on the tools and training provided by their agency. That unfortunately included taking a defensive stance and using reload methods unsuited for combat.

There is a wider lesson in the Newhall Massacre, the impact of which is only underscored by the shock value. This event serves as a reminder that the teachings of yesterday do not necessarily prepare us for today. It is a warning that continuing to perform the same task in the same way can be a prescription for failure. It exposes our most sacred mantra, “This is the way we’ve always done it,” as a false truth.

There is real value in such a message. Far beyond the realm of police work, there is a constant need to rethink our notions, preconceived or otherwise. Whether the topic is race, gender issues, politics or any other contentious issue, we can and should look to the past for example and guidance. But we need to recognize that the status quo of yesteryear is no longer in front of us – it is slipping past in the rearview mirror.

That is the lesson that has resonated for me. Since it came at the cost of the lives of four young men, I am passing it on in their honor.

Leave a comment Comments → 6
  1. smokey984 says:

    And since Police work is inherently reactive in nature you are always at the disadvantage. Especially when first responders have a set of rules to follow and the bad guys don’t. Same problem, different day…

    As experienced from my last combat deployment to Afghanistan ending in May 2011, i can relate…Bad guys never follow the rules. And those of us who serve in “Pick ur profession” Uniform we do have to follow the ROE, Use of Force guidelines ETC ETC…

    Good point, in your article, concerning the mindset and consistently fighting complacency. That mindset has saved us probably more than we care to know.

  2. ithsmay says:

    Thank you for this article!
    If police officers are to risk their lives daily, they need the best training and the best weaponry possible.

  3. elmerfudd says:

    Skilled marksmen are few and far between even among groups where you would think they would be common, (like soldiers). Among criminals I imagine they are like hen’s teeth, (witness the popularity of the sideways hold). These officers had the misfortune to run into not one, but two of them. This would have been an extremely dangerous situation even in ideal circumstances. The criminals in question had amassed a small arsenal and spent the day practicing with it. One of them had also boasted of his desire to kill a cop.

  4. Reiker01 says:

    We studied Newhall in detail when I went through the academy in ’76. If there can be any good to come out of it, it revolutionized our training in what we call “Officer Survival” today. No more “Hoe, Hum…just another traffic stop, bank alarm, Etc….”

    That, and many trainings since, has saved my butt more than once.

  5. when people remember newhall, two things about the incident are most often recalled: one, 4 california highway patrol officers were killed in one incident; the other, spent brass were found in one of the officer’s pocket after his murder.

    i have been a researcher on the newhall shootings since the early 1970’s. the “brass in the pocket” story is a myth. it never happened at newhall. officer pence ejected his spent brass onto the ground and all of the brass were located under his body after the scene was cleared by responding officers. this myth does a great disservice to the memory of chp officer james pence and the california highway patrol.


  6. Brian O'Neill says:

    I appreciate your comments, Ed, but the content must be a state secret. As I mentioned, I have been the recipient of the “Newhall Scenario” training at least three times in the past. Each time there was mention of the brass shells being placed in the pocket (a factor which would only discredit CHP range training and not the officer himself).

    Perhaps you could make the correction in Wikipedia and get the story straight, if indeed you have the facts to back it up?

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0