Blue Byline

A cop's perspective of the news and South Sound matters

Amanda Knox finally seeing a little justice

Post by Brian O'Neill on June 30, 2011 at 8:36 am with 4 Comments »
July 4, 2011 10:08 am

For a person in Amanda Knox’ shoes, the latest news from an Italian appellate court must be as welcome as it is painful. Welcome because it represents her first glimpse of hope and possible release from her lengthy sentence; painful because of the potential that this solitary piece of good news may be a false hope.

Either way, Knox finally had a good day in court. The Trib story (6-30) describes an Italian appellate court’s reaction after taking a good look at forensic evidence from Knox’ case. The state of the DNA specimen was lousy, or malvagio if you prefer Google’s version of the lingua Italia. The appellate court was not pleased.

Knox and her family, who have waited since November 2007 for this type of response, are hoping that her murder conviction is dismissed.

And it does appear that this most unlikely of cases is starting to unravel in Knox’ favor. Let’s face it, the idea that a 23-year old college student, with no indications of depravity other than smoking dope with her Italian lover, would be deeply involved in a sex act culminating in the brutal stabbing of her roommate sounds…well, it sounds ridiculous.

It would be a ridiculous supposition, that is, unless the prosecution were to provide a plausible motive or obvious character flaw that would give any hint of Knox being a capable and willing accomplice to murder. Did they?


As in all such cases of circumstantial evidence, we will be left to wonder what really happened. It is certainly possible that Knox was a party to her roommate’s homicide, yet that almost absurd argument is esteemed only by an Italian prosecution that better resembled a slip-shod witch hunt conducted at a snail’s pace.

Hopefully the Italian appeals court won’t drag its heels much longer, and the final act of this long and arduous debacle will have a swift conclusion. If so, Knox could soon find herself back home in Seattle. She would then be able to relax and take stock of her life after spending four years grinding through the stuck gears of Italian justice.

I hope that happens, for Knox and her family.

Leave a comment Comments → 4
  1. Thanks, Brian, for an excellent post. This case is taking so long and is so painful, but I have faith that it will end well for Amanda and Raffaele. I just hope there is some way that Mignini and crew are forced to pay for the misery they have caused, and for the Knox and Sollecito families to at least collect damages for the financial cost if not the emotional and physical. I also hope that there will be retribution for the disgusting, unethical hacks, like Barbie Latza Nadeau and Nick Pisa, that have used this tragedy for their own greedy gain.

    Again, thanks for the great article!!!

  2. vasocreta says:

    This is such a frustrating story. The Knox family must be clinging to this breakthrough with every ounce of strength.

    On a less important note: it is “malvagio” not “molvagio”. “Mal” comes from the latin, meaning “bad” ;-)

  3. Brian O'Neill says:

    Thanks for the correction, vasocreta. I could swear that the Google translator spelled it with an “o” but I’ll change it either way.

    And joancj- It would appear you are very familiar with this case. Feel free to share any further insights on this blog. Since you mentioned some future civil issues, my personal hope is that if/when Amanda is released that she returns and simply gets on with her life. I have watched others, including fellow police officers, pursue injustice through civil courts. Regardless of the outcome, that ordeal was too close a reminder of the original incident and a drain on their psyche.

    Meanwhile, let’s cross our fingers.

  4. I can only go by what I’ve read in the media. That said, this sure looks like a frame up.

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part and abiding by these simple rules.

JavaScript is required to post comments.

Follow the comments on this post with RSS 2.0